There has been a growing campaign internationally in the non-profit/charity sectors over recent years for employers to include a salary range when conducting job searches rather than utilizing vague terms like “competitive” or commiserate with experience.”
The Show The Salary website was started in the UK, but people in the United States and Canada have taken up the cause. People like Nonprofit AF blogger Vu Le frequently make Twitter posts directed at employers using the hashtag #showthesalary. Vu Le generally includes the sentence “Please always #ShowTheSalary, as not doing so perpetuates racial and gender wage gaps.”
Hello @nationwidekids @NCHCareers I noticed you don’t show salary range on this job posting. Please always #ShowTheSalary, as not doing so perpetuates racial and gender wage gaps. Also, requiring a BA for non-specialized positions is inequitable https://t.co/pc397r1W0R
— Vu Le (@NonprofitAF) June 25, 2021
The Show The Salary website expands upon the reasons why organizations should list salaries
2. You’ll make it a fairer process
There’s ample evidence that salary negotiation is not a fair process. For example, negotiation behaviours are perceived very differently depending on if it’s a man or a woman doing the negotiating. And Black candidates are often discriminated against and secure far lower salaries than their white counterparts. We’ve also heard direct stories from working class and LGBTQIA+ candidates that they have been discriminated against during the negotiation process.
So by hiding the salary, and relying on negotiation, you’re immediately putting these candidates at a disadvantage.
As well as debunking many of the rationales employers use to avoid listing them. (emphasis added to distinguish statements and responses)
“We have internal pay disparity and don’t want staff seeing other’s salaries”
We’d suggest dealing with the pay disparity rather than adding to it.
“The low pay will put people off”
Then pay a fair wage. They’ll be put off once they find out the salary anyway.
“The high pay will put people off”
You’ve benchmarked the role? Then it’s a fair salary, not a high one. And if you genuinely believe the pay will put people off, then maybe your job description / person specification isn’t clear enough on skills and experience needed. If you’re coupling a higher-level salary with a request for someone’s current salary then, yes, some people might not apply because, on paper, they won’t look like the right fit. But if your JD is right, you don’t ask for salary history then we don’t think you’ve got anything to worry about – remember, ads with salaries get around twice as many applicants.
There are a number of states and cities which prohibit employers from either asking you to provide your salary history and/or using the omission of salary history in an application as the basis for not hiring someone. In some cases these laws only apply to government employees or government contractors, in others it applies to all employers within the jurisdiction.
However, at the time of this post only Colorado requires all employers with a presence in the state to include a salary range and benefits in job postings. As a result, many companies seeking employees to work remotely are specifically excluding Colorado residents from applying, or as in the case of Nike, say Coloradans who are hired will be required to move out of the state before performing any work.
The fact there is such strong resistance to including salary and benefits in job listings may indicate this will become a hot button issue in social and political discourse in coming years.
In the meantime, how job searches are conducted, including salary listings should be a serious consideration among all arts organizations, commercial or non-profit. At the time of this writing, there is a plethora of job listings in the arts, including an astounding number at the executive level. Not only will salary listings make positions more attractive to talented individuals, the internal conversations about the hiring process will create precedent and organizational cultural values going forward.